Tea Rooms.org
Sugarplums & Teas, Lancaster, Pennsylvania

Sugarplums & Teas

Lancaster, Pennsylvania

Afternoon TeaVintage & Historic

Lancaster tea room serving high tea on a three-tiered server with freshly baked scones, savories such as spinach-and-feta puff pastry and Hawaiian chicken salad, and made-from-scratch desserts. An ever-changing lunch menu, loose-leaf teas and tea accessories are also offered. Reservations are highly recommended.

Known For

  • Three-tiered high tea
  • Freshly baked scones
  • Made-from-scratch pastries
  • Loose-leaf teas
  • Lunch menu

Menu & Pricing

Full menu ↗

Courtyard Tea / High Tea

  • Our Three-Tiered High Tea$26.95Soup or fruit, four seasonal savories, trio of sweets, and tea
  • Garden Tea$16.00Savory, salad, fruit, half scone with lemon curd, and tea
  • Trio of Savories$16.00Three savories, salad, and tea

Salads

  • Fresh Garden Salad$14.50Mixed garden greens topped with fresh chicken salad served with poppy seed dressing
  • Apple Walnut Grilled Chicken Salad$15.50Spring mix with apples, craisins, bleu cheese and grilled chicken
  • Grilled Chicken Salad$15.50Mixed greens topped with chicken breast, steamed broccoli, cashews, and red onion, with cherry tomatoes and poppy seed dressing

Sandwiches

  • Tuna Melt$14.75Tuna on ciabatta bread topped with cheddar cheese and tomato, served with a side salad
  • Turkey Bacon Wrap$14.50Fresh turkey breast and crisp bacon with spring mix, garlic cream cheese and onion jam
  • Hawaiian Chicken Salad$14.50Chicken salad with roasted pineapple habanero sauce and fresh pineapple on wheatberry bread
  • Grilled Ham & Swiss$14.50Thinly sliced baked ham with Swiss cheese, pickle, and grainy mustard on a grilled panini
  • Short Rib Sandwich$14.75Black Angus short rib on a Kaiser roll with lettuce, tomato, and mozzarella, served with sweet potato fries
  • Cheeseburger Sliders$14.50Three certified Angus beef burgers with cheddar and red pepper mayo on brioche, with boardwalk fries
  • Veggie Panini$14.25Roasted vegetables, feta and mozzarella on a grilled panini

Entrees & More

  • Quiche of the Day$14.50Served with a side salad
  • Fish & Chips$14.75Beer batter white fish served with boardwalk fries
  • Quesadilla$14.75Grilled chicken with roasted veggies and cheddar, served with boardwalk fries
  • Turkey & Brie$14.50Oven-roasted turkey with brie and cranberry cream cheese on ciabatta, with a fresh garden salad

Prices from the venue's published menu, verified 2026-08-12. Menus change — confirm with the room.

The Editorial Review

Our editors haven't visited Sugarplums & Teas yet. Every room in the directory gets a full sit-down editorial review — the pour, the service, the room itself. This one is on the route.

Visitor Reviews

No visitor reviews yet — be the first to write one below.

Review Sugarplums & Teas