Asterisk Supper Club
Historic Uptown Westerville · Westerville, Ohio
Afternoon Tea
Supper club in historic Uptown Westerville specializing in afternoon tea, elevated comfort food, and craft cocktails. Afternoon tea is served 12 PM to 4 PM Tuesday through Sunday, styled as a throwback to gathering around the supper table.
Known For
- Afternoon tea service (12–4 PM Tue–Sun)
- Elevated comfort food
- Craft cocktails
- Private parties and catering
Menu & Pricing
Full menu ↗Afternoon tea served 12 PM to 4 PM Tuesday through Sunday
Afternoon Tea
- Cream Tea$12Choice of tea, 2 scones, clotted cream and jam
- Petite Tea$32Choice of tea, choice of soup or salad, 5 tea sandwiches, 1 scone, 1 dessert
- Full Tea$60Choice of 2 teas, choice of 2 soups or salads, variety of 10 tea sandwiches, 2 scones and 2 desserts
Starters
- Seared Tuna$15Coriander crusted with wasabi mayo
- Poutine$16
- Spinach and Artichoke Dip$15
- Mushroom Toast—Whipped ricotta and goat cheese, braised wild mushrooms, burnt honey
Sandwiches & Mains
- Asterisk Burger$19
- Asterisk Famous Chicken Sandwich$17
- Classic Grilled Cheese$16
Desserts
- Chef Christie's Famous Cinnamon Roll$13
- Butter Cake$10
- Vegan Chocolate Torte$10
Prices from the venue's published menu, verified 2026-08-12. Menus change — confirm with the room.
The Editorial Review
Our editors haven't visited Asterisk Supper Club yet. Every room in the directory gets a full sit-down editorial review — the pour, the service, the room itself. This one is on the route.
Visitor Reviews
No visitor reviews yet — be the first to write one below.